Navigation Bar - Text Links at Bottom of Page

WHY DO FOOLS FALL IN LOVE?

by: Scott Renshaw

I can understand why screenwriter Tina Andrews latched onto the story behind Why Do Fools Fall in Love for fifteen years. From a commercial standpoint, it has a great hook: the real-life story of three women who all claimed to be the legal widow of Frankie Lymon, who led the 1950s doo-wop group the Teenagers to several hit songs, including the one from which the film draws its title. From a writer's standpoint, it offers the intriguing contradiction of its main character, a troubled soul who seemed to be three different people to his three different brides before dying of a drug overdose in 1968. It's a story with sex, drugs and rock 'n' roll, as well as colorful characters a-plenty. Sure enough, this bio-pic offers loads of curb appeal.

Unfortunately, Andrews made a big mistake in her approach to the material - she decided to turn Why Do Fools Fall in Love into a rock 'n' roll Rashomon. The framing story opens in 1986, with three women - former Platters singer Zola Taylor (Halle Berry), petty thief and single mom Elizabeth Waters (Vivica A. Fox), and schoolteacher Emira Eagle (Lela Rochon) - all making the legal claim to be Mrs. Frankie Lymon, with rights to his musical royalties. A hearing commences in which each claimant tells the story of Frankie (Larenz Tate) as she knew him, from teen star to has-been, from heroin addict to soldier. The flashbacks cover 13 years of Frankie's life, with widely varying perspectives on the complex man each of the three women married at some point during that span, but none of them divorced.

Somewhere buried in the narrative is an interesting, if somewhat clichéd, entertainment industry life story, the story of a street kid from an abusive home who becomes dependent on the love he receives from audiences and his women. Larenz Tate does a fine job of re-creating Frankie's electrifying stage presence, as well as his sheer joy of performing. In fact, the high-energy performance scenes are generally the film's best, re-creating the era's innocent enthusiasm and classy look contrasted with Frankie's bolder charisma and sex appeal. Tate also has the thankless job of creating a character out of piecemeal recollections, yet the character still comes together as someone you might want to know more about.

If only wanting made it so. Only occasionally does Why Do Fools Fall in Love hone in on the question of who Frankie Lymon really was. Too often Andrews and director Gregory Nava (Selena) take off on ill-advised tangents - a vamping, self-indulgent cameo appearance by Little Richard as himself; the hit-and-run accusation that Frankie's manager Morris Levy (Paul Mazursky) cheated him out of millions; a broadly comic female bonding session which turns Zola, Elizabeth and Emira into the First, Second and Third Wives' Club. When they finally do get around to Frankie himself, the answers they offer are as psychologically convenient as the shattered mirror in which Frankie sees his fragmented face in one scene. Ultimately no one, not even the three women with whom he shared a life, seems interested in understanding Frankie. It's easier to dismiss him as a messed-up junkie con man and get on with carving up his estate.

That's what is most disappointing about Why Do Fools Fall in Love?: it's not really the biography of Frankie Lymon at all. Andrews and Nava are more interested in getting inside the heads of the three women - making them all sympathetic, mis-used you-go-girls - than getting inside Frankie's head. Sure, they violate point of view when it serves their purposes (showing things none of the narrators could have seen), but mostly they're interested in pointing out how Frankie's enigmatic behavior hurt others, not how he hurt himself. It's a cop-out for film-makers to start telling a character's story, then shrug their shoulders and claim not to have any idea who that character is. Tina

TOP

Home | Theaters | Video | TV

Your Comments and Suggestions are Always Welcome.
Contact CinemaReview.com 

© 2014 Cinema Review,  All Rights Reserved.

Google


Find:  HELP!

Google